RupeeKit Logo

Index Fund vs Active Fund Cost Calculator India

Enter your values

Estimated results

Future value before fund costs

₹27,36,783

Index-fund net return assumption

11.80%

Active-fund net return assumption

10.50%

Index-fund future value

₹26,64,385

Active-fund future value

₹22,35,652

Index-fund cost drag

₹72,397

Active-fund cost drag

₹5,01,131

Future-value difference from costs

₹4,28,734
Detailed breakdown

Result visual

Compare outputs within each unit group. Bars show magnitude; exact values include any negative sign. Each group uses its own scale.

Amounts (Rs)

Future value before fund costs₹27,36,783
Index-fund future value₹26,64,385
Active-fund future value₹22,35,652
Index-fund cost drag₹72,397

Percentages (%)

Index-fund net return assumption11.80%
Active-fund net return assumption10.50%
Inputs used in this result
Lumpsum investment
5,00,000 Rs
Investment period
15 years
Expected gross annual return
12 %
Index-fund expense ratio
0.2 %
Active-fund expense ratio
1.5 %

Share this calculator scenario

Educational estimate only

How to use this calculator

Compare how two expense ratios change future value when both funds earn the same assumed gross return before costs.

Written and reviewed by RupeeKit Editorial TeamLast reviewed 5 August 2026Report a correction
Indian investor measuring two fund-growth paths to compare long-term expense-ratio drag
Indian investor measuring two fund-growth paths to compare long-term expense-ratio drag

Educational estimate only

Results can vary based on company policy, lender terms, tax law, and personal assumptions.

Fund cost-drag comparison

Quick Answer

What does this index-vs-active calculator compare? It holds the assumed gross return constant and compares how different expense ratios affect future value. It is a fee-drag comparison, not a forecast that index or active funds will outperform.

Formula used

Subtracts each expense ratio from the same assumed gross return and compounds both net return assumptions for the selected period.

Example calculation

For a ₹5,00,000 lumpsum held for 15 years, assume both funds earn 12% a year before costs. An index-fund expense ratio of 0.2% gives an 11.8% net return assumption and about ₹26.64 lakh. An active-fund expense ratio of 1.5% gives a 10.5% net return assumption and about ₹22.36 lakh. The modelled difference is about ₹4.29 lakh from fees alone. These constant-return assumptions exclude tax, exit loads and tracking differences; they do not forecast either fund's actual performance.

This page isolates expense-ratio drag

The purpose is to answer a cost question, not a SIP-return question. Both fund routes use the same assumed gross return so the output shows the mathematical effect of recurring fund expenses over time.

FAQs

Does a lower expense ratio guarantee a higher return?

No. This calculator deliberately holds gross return constant to isolate cost drag. Actual fund performance, tracking difference and portfolio choices vary.

Does this include exit load or tax?

No. It compares recurring expense ratios only and excludes one-time charges, transaction costs and tax.

Should I use this page to calculate my SIP corpus?

Use the regular or Step-Up SIP calculator for contribution-based corpus projections. Use this page when the question is specifically the long-term cost difference between expense ratios.